Third Republic Initiative Audit

Digital Governance
Report Card

Before a citizen can access a service, file a complaint, or find information, they must get through a government website. We tested India's most-used government portals for speed, reliability, mobile readiness and usability. The results are a mirror on how the state thinks about citizens.

24
Websites audited
5
Dimensions scored
—
Average score / 100
—
Sites graded D or F
⚡
Availability (20 pts)
Uptime over 30-day monitoring window. Timeout rate during peak hours.
🤖 UptimeRobot — automated
🏎
Speed (20 pts)
Time to first byte and full page load on a standard 4G mobile connection.
🤖 PageSpeed Insights — automated
📱
Mobile (20 pts)
PageSpeed mobile score plus manual spot-check on a Redmi Note 12 device.
⚡ Partial — tool + human check
🔒
Security (20 pts)
Valid HTTPS certificate. No mixed content. No expired SSL warnings.
🤖 SSL Labs API — automated
🧭
Usability (20 pts)
First-time user attempts to complete the main citizen task. Clicks and time recorded.
👤 Human tester required
Grade key: A  80–100 B  60–79 C  40–59 D  20–39 F  Below 20 All scores pending first audit. See instructions below for how to collect each score.
Show:
🔍
📋
Phased audit — scores are being added in stages. Security and Speed can be measured using free automated tools (SSL Labs, PageSpeed Insights) and take about a day for all 24 sites. Availability requires 30 days of uptime monitoring before a score is valid. Mobile scoring is partly automated, partly a manual device check. Usability requires a human tester for each site and takes longest.
Phase 1: Security + Speed — Pending Phase 2: Availability (30-day window) — Pending Phase 3: Mobile spot-checks — Pending Phase 4: Usability testing — Pending
Tier 1 — Central Government Portals
8 sites · Services used by 100M+ citizens

The flagship portals of central government — income tax filing, Aadhaar management, passport applications, railway booking, provident fund. These are the sites that most directly determine whether a citizen can access the state without visiting an office.

Tier 2 — State Government Portals
7 sites · One per major state

State governments are the primary delivery mechanism for most citizen services — caste certificates, land records, ration cards, building permits. These portals vary enormously in quality, revealing sharp differences in state-level governance capacity.

Tier 3 — Municipal Corporation Websites
9 sites · The 10 largest cities

The digital face of city government — property tax, trade licences, grievance filing, ward information. For most urban citizens, these are the portals that matter most for daily life. They are also, consistently, the worst performing.

How to collect each score

Each dimension uses a free, publicly available tool. No account needed for most. Work through the sites in one tier at a time — doing all 24 in one sitting takes roughly a full day. Open this page alongside the tools below and enter scores directly into the scores array for each site in the JavaScript.

🔒
Dimension 1 — Security (20 pts)
Tool: SSL Labs  ·  Time: ~3 min/site  ·  🤖 Automatable
Step 1. Go to ssllabs.com/ssltest and paste the site URL. Tick "Do not show the results on the boards" to keep it private. Click Submit and wait 60–90 seconds for the full report.

Step 2. Note the overall letter grade at the top of the results page. Convert to a score out of 20 using this table:
SSL Labs Grade Score /20 What it means
A+20Exceptional — HSTS enforced, modern TLS only
A18Strong — valid cert, no major issues
A-16Good — minor config issues (e.g. no HSTS)
B12Acceptable — older TLS versions still enabled
C8Weak — significant configuration problems
F / T0Fail — expired cert, untrusted, or no HTTPS
Site unreachable0Record as 0 and note in verdict field
Also note: Scroll down in the SSL Labs report and check for "Mixed content" warnings (HTTP resources loaded on HTTPS page). If present, deduct 2 points. Record your finding in the site's verdict field.
🏎
Dimension 2 — Speed (20 pts)
Tool: PageSpeed Insights  ·  Time: ~2 min/site  ·  🤖 Automatable
Step 1. Go to pagespeed.web.dev, paste the URL, and click Analyse. Wait for results (30–60 seconds).

Step 2. Switch to the Mobile tab (not Desktop — mobile is the relevant test given that most Indians access government sites on phones).

Step 3. Note the Performance score (the large number, 0–100, at the top). Convert to a score /20 using this formula:
Speed score = round(PageSpeed Mobile score ÷ 5)
Example: PageSpeed score 72 → Speed score 72 ÷ 5 = 14 / 20

Also record the First Contentful Paint and Time to Interactive values from the Diagnostics section — paste these into the verdict field. They make the score concrete and citeable.

⚠ Run each site three times and take the middle score — PageSpeed results vary by ±5 points between runs due to server load variation. Do all three runs within 5 minutes of each other. Record the median.
⚡
Dimension 3 — Availability (20 pts)
Tool: UptimeRobot (free)  ·  Setup: 30 min, then 30-day wait  ·  🤖 Automatable
One-time setup (do this first, before anything else).
Go to uptimerobot.com and create a free account. The free tier allows 50 monitors checking every 5 minutes — enough for all 24 sites.

Step 1. For each site, click Add New Monitor. Set Monitor Type: HTTP(s). Paste the URL. Set check interval: 5 minutes. Click Save.

Step 2. Wait 30 days. UptimeRobot will send email alerts on downtime. Check back after 30 days and note the uptime percentage for each site.

Step 3. Convert uptime percentage to a score /20:
30-day Uptime % Score /20 Notes
99.9% +20Under 44 min downtime/month
99.0–99.9%16Under 7.2 hrs downtime/month
97.0–99.0%12Up to ~22 hrs downtime/month
90.0–97.0%8Frequent or extended outages
Below 90%4Unreliable — more than 72 hrs down
Site unreachable0Did not respond during monitoring window
Important: Some government sites block monitoring bots. If UptimeRobot repeatedly shows "seems down" for a site you can clearly access in a browser, the site is blocking the monitor. In that case, manually check the site once a week for 4 weeks and estimate availability. Note this in the verdict field.
📱
Dimension 4 — Mobile Readiness (20 pts)
Tool: PageSpeed + Manual device check  ·  Time: ~10 min/site  ·  ⚡ Partial — tool + human
Mobile scoring has two parts — automated (10 pts) and manual (10 pts).

Part A — Automated (10 pts): Use the same PageSpeed Insights run from the Speed dimension. Under Diagnostics → Opportunities, check for these specific failures. Deduct points as shown:
PageSpeed flag Deduct
"Does not have a <meta name=viewport> tag"−4 pts
"Tap targets are not sized appropriately"−3 pts
"Text is too small to read"−2 pts
"Content wider than screen"−1 pt
No flags — clean mobile diagnosticsFull 10 pts
Part B — Manual device check (10 pts): Open the site on a real Android phone (mid-range preferred — Redmi, Realme, or Samsung M-series). Use Chrome. Score each item below as pass (2 pts) or fail (0 pts):
  1. Homepage loads without horizontal scroll
  2. Main navigation is tappable without zooming
  3. The primary form (login, search, or application) is usable without zooming in
  4. Site does not prompt to download an app as a prerequisite to use it
  5. No "Best viewed in Internet Explorer" or "Use desktop mode" warnings
Record Part A + Part B scores in the verdict. Total mobile score = Part A + Part B.
🧭
Dimension 5 — Usability (20 pts)
Method: Human task testing  ·  Time: ~20 min/site  ·  👤 Human tester required
The tester must be someone who has never used the site before. Brief them on the task, start a timer, and observe — do not help them.

The standard task for each site tier:
  • Central portals: Find and begin the most common citizen task (e.g. on incometax.gov.in: reach the ITR filing login page; on passportindia.gov.in: reach the appointment booking page; on epfindia.gov.in: reach the member passbook)
  • State portals: Find where to apply for an income certificate or caste certificate
  • Municipal portals: Find where to pay property tax online
Scoring rubric (20 pts total):
Criterion Points How to score
Task reachable0 or 88 if tester reaches the task page; 0 if they give up or reach a dead end
Clicks to reach task0–61–2 clicks = 6 pts; 3–4 clicks = 4 pts; 5–6 = 2 pts; 7+ = 0 pts
Time to reach task0–4Under 1 min = 4 pts; 1–3 min = 2 pts; over 3 min = 0 pts
No broken links encountered0 or 22 if no 404 or dead ends; 0 if any encountered on the path
Record: the exact task given, number of clicks, time taken, tester's first name and occupation (for transparency), and any notable observations. Paste a short summary into the site's verdict field.

⚠ Tester must be a genuine first-time user. Someone who has visited a government portal before — even briefly — has unconscious familiarity that inflates the score. Use a friend, family member, or colleague who does not regularly interact with government websites. Ideally test with 2–3 different people and average.
Quick reference — entering scores into the page

Once you have scores, open digital_governance.html in a text editor and find the SITES array. Each site has a scores field in this order:

scores: [availability, speed, mobile, security, usability]
// Each value: 0–20, or null if not yet tested

// Example — Security + Speed done, rest pending:
scores: [null, 14, null, 18, null]

// Example — fully scored:
scores: [16, 14, 12, 18, 10]

The grade badge, score bars, and hero statistics update automatically. Also update the verdict field with your key findings, and change lastTested to the month you tested (e.g. 'May 2026').

International Benchmark

How do India's central government portals compare to equivalent services in other countries? These scores apply the same five-dimension framework to comparable citizen service portals.

Country Portal Grade Notes
🇪🇪 Estonia
e-Residency / State Portal
eesti.ee / e-residency.gov.ee A Industry benchmark. Single login for all government services. Full functionality on mobile. Sub-2 second load times nationally.
🇸🇬 Singapore
Singpass / MyInfo
singpass.gov.sg A Unified national digital identity used for 2,000+ services. Near-zero downtime. Genuine mobile-first design.
🇬🇧 United Kingdom
GOV.UK
gov.uk A Global standard for government UX. Plain-language design, accessibility-first, consistent across departments.
🇧🇷 Brazil
gov.br
gov.br B Significant improvement post-2019 unification. Strong mobile app. Some legacy ministry portals still fragmented.
🇰🇷 South Korea
Government24
gov24.kr B Excellent speed and availability. Loses points for complexity — too many services, navigation requires prior familiarity.
🇮🇳 India
india.gov.in (National Portal)
india.gov.in TBD Audit in progress. See full results in Tier 1 above.
What every government website should be able to do

These are not aspirational goals. They are baseline expectations. Any government website that cannot meet them is failing citizens.

⚡
Load in under 3 seconds
On a standard 4G mobile connection — which is how most Indians access the internet. A site that takes 14 seconds to load is not a website. It is a deterrent.
📱
Work on any smartphone
Without pinching, horizontal scrolling, or a separate app download. 750 million Indians access the internet via phone. A desktop-only portal is a class filter.
🔁
Not lose your work
Session timeouts that discard filled forms — without warning — are a design choice that punishes citizens for the government's infrastructure limitations.
📋
Confirm every submission
Every form submission should produce an acknowledgement number. Citizens should be able to track their application status without calling an office.
🔒
Be secure by default
HTTPS is not optional. An expired SSL certificate on a portal collecting Aadhaar or bank details is a serious security failure, not a minor oversight.
🗺
Let you find things
The main service of a portal should be reachable in three clicks or fewer by a first-time visitor. Navigation designed for bureaucrats is not navigation for citizens.

Work on a government digital team?

We're happy to share your site's detailed scorecard before publication, and to discuss what improvements would most improve your score.

Get in touch →